Head-to-head comparison · 2026
Phidias vs TradeDay
Side-by-side on the metrics that actually matter: true cost to funded, drawdown type, profit split and payout speed.
Market
Futures
Futures
Founded
2024
2020
Total cost to funded
Best$164
$175
Eval cost
$164
$175
Activation fee
-
-
Pricing model
One-time
Monthly sub
Challenge type
1-Step
1-Step
Drawdown type
EOD
EOD
Max profit split
90%
Best95%
First profit
80% to 90%
80% → 90% → 95% tiered by lifetime withdrawal
Payout speed
48h eval-to-payout
Day 1 (next business day)
Max account
Best$300K
$150K
Consistency rule
30% rule
30% eval only
News trading
Allowed
Restricted
Platforms
TradingViewNinjaTrader
TradovateNinjaTraderJigsaw DayTradrTradingView
Strengths & watch-outs
Phidias
Strengths
- Very fast eval-to-payout
- Real-time compliance dashboard
- EOD drawdown
Watch-outs
- Tighter 30% consistency rule
- Newer firm (2024)
- Fewer platforms
TradeDay
Strengths
- Day-1 payouts, no minimum waiting period
- Tiered split scales to 95% over lifetime withdrawals
- 7 platform options, the most in futures prop space
Watch-outs
- News trading restricted, auto-liquidates around Tier 1 events
- Monthly subscription, costs add up if you take time to pass
- Only 3 funded sim accounts simultaneously
🐨 PropKoala verdict
Phidias is cheaper to get funded at $164 total. TradeDay offers a higher max split at 95%. Both use EOD or static drawdown, a plus for both.
This verdict is generated from our verified data. Always check each firm's current terms before purchasing.
Figures are list prices for the 50K account, last updated Sep 2026. Verify all details directly with each firm before purchasing. PropKoala may earn affiliate commissions. Trading involves substantial risk.