Side-by-side on the metrics that actually matter: true cost to funded, drawdown type, profit split and payout speed.
Quick verdict
Lucid Trading is $76 cheaper to get funded on a 50K account ($94 vs $170, activation fees included).
E8 Futures uses end-of-day drawdown, which is more forgiving than Lucid Trading's intraday trailing drawdown. Open profit that you give back doesn't count against you.
E8 Futures has a consistency rule on the funded account, which can hold up payouts after a big day. Lucid Trading doesn't. Rule: None on eval, 35% funded.
Lucid Trading pays out faster (daily vs first payout in 3 days).
Lucid Trading has the higher maximum profit split, 90% against 80%.
Figures are list prices for the 50K account (or the closest size a firm offers). Verify all details directly with each firm before purchasing. PropKoala may earn affiliate commissions. Trading involves substantial risk.